Older Adults' Perceptions of Frailty and Advance Care Planning (ACP)

Abstract ID
3793
Authors' names
V Barber-Fleming1; G Mead 2; H Wilkinson1,
Author's provenances
1. Advanced Care Research Centre, University of Edinburgh; 2. Usher Institute, University of Edinburgh
Abstract category
Abstract sub-category
Conditions

Abstract

Introduction

Advanced care planning (ACP) is particularly relevant for those living with frailty, who are at heightened risk of sudden health changes and loss of cognitive ability. The concepts of frailty and ACP are understood differently by older adults and health care professionals (HCPs). This abstract represents the qualitative component of a mixed methods study aiming to evaluate older people’s perspectives of frailty, including how and why they build self-perceptions of frailty, and their perceptions of ACP.

Method

Ten community dwelling, older adults, (aged seventy years plus), registered with a single GP practice, were interviewed, alongside a ‘close person’ if they wished. Participants were purposively sampled from a pool of survey respondents. Semi structured interviews were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis.

Results

Four themes were identified: ‘Focus on the familiar first’, ‘Dependency: the good, the bad and the ugly’, “If you don’t use it, you will lose it”; don’t give in to frailty – keep going, ‘Attitudes towards frailty matter; you need to have mental grit’. ACP is not familiar to most older people and family is often consulted before HCPs. What people want to plan for may not be health related. Being independent and able to keep going were key to many older people’s frailty identity. Some older adults feel there is a choice in how one responds to frailty, placing great importance on having a positive mental attitude.

Conclusions

Understanding older people’s priorities for future planning can help HCPs to engage in ACP conversations with an open mind. Knowing that families have often already been involved in future planning discussions may allow a ‘way in’. Insights into how older people construct their frailty identity, and the importance placed on positive attitudes, keeping going and independence, may allow for conversations to be more aligned with their values. 

Comments

Although recommended, many people don't want to go through the formal process. Starting conversations can be as important as finishing (i.e. formal ACP).

Submitted by stephen.wilkinson on

Permalink

Thank you for your comment, Stephen. Your words align with evidence from a survey of community dwelling older people in England (Musa et al., 2015) which found they would prefer informal discussion with family to formal ACP. 

Musa, I, Seymour, J, Narayanasamy, M et al. A survey of older peoples' attitudes towards advance care planning. Age Ageing 2015, 44(3):371-376. doi:10.1093/ageing/afv041  

Submitted by V.A.Barber-Fle… on

In reply to by stephen.wilkinson

Permalink

The themes presented here are interesting for clinicians hoping to start the conversation about advanced care planning and the future. I don’t think we are giving patients and their families enough space to discuss this before formalising the discussion with a HCP. Given the rise of using digital tools to identify frailty, should we be sending out information on what advanced care planning is and allow patients to explore this with their relatives before it is discussed with a clinician (which often occurs at hospital admission). 

Submitted by catherine.penman on

Permalink

Thank you for your comment, Catherine. I found that often people had already had discussions with their families about what mattered to them. Exploring this with patients may be a useful starting point. What older adults want to plan for may not align with what health care professionals think of as ACP. I think further research is needed to understand what older adults want to plan for and how we support this while making sure they are informed about the health care system and options genuinely open to them in relation to their health and care.